Articles & News About Student Loans & School

Unintended Consequences of True School Choice

I always try to make it a point to see both sides of an education issue, and as Project Runway host Tim Gunn always tells his fashion designer cast, try to make it work.

The concept of true school choice fits that challenge.

The thought behind true school choice is that "dollars follow the child." Parents receive a government-estimated amount of money which represents the cost of educating each of their children, with adjustments for special needs such as special education, English language skills and physical disabilities. Parents may apply those monies it towards any school they choose: public, private, parochial or even home schooling. The state takes charge of informing parents of their options; public school superintendents and local school boards would have little incentive to do it.

True-choice advocates say this puts the decisions on quality schools in the hands of the parents, in effect creating a marketplace for education. It also, in theory, would provide "seed capital" for parents who could home-school their children or join with other parents to form a school of their own. It could also help parents create a more personalized educational experience for their child; for instance, they could elect to send him or her to college a year early. True choice assumes all parents also have equal access to perfect information to make an informed decision.

I understand why school boards and public school teacher's unions would be opposed to true choice; average and poor-performing schools could be the losers in the market place, as their students would be likely to seek alternatives. I do, however, agree with true choice advocates that competition would make these schools adjust and perform to new circumstances or deservedly close their doors.

True choice empowers parents, and therefore takes power away from local school boards. School boards are thrust into the role of marketers to try to identify and fill local needs, as well as teach the state's standard curriculum. That's good and bad; they could, for example, offer high school courses directed at post-graduation jobs with local employers, or college-prep SAT tutoring, but be forced to send their constituents elsewhere for needs that can't be filled. Elsewhere can mean a school further from home, where parents must provide transportation. Three words to those school boards: disgruntled parents remember.

But proponents of true choice also ask for less government intervention in the schools; they prefer that parents and teachers choose the academic program with little to no involvement from state government. I don't believe that's possible; in fact, government may need to be involved where it has not been involved before.

For one thing, public money would be sent to schools where it has never been sent before. The private and parochial institutions would have to be help accountable for that money, as would those who home school. At the very least, state governments would be likely to set standards for teacher-student contact hours or days as well as the submission of attendance records. They could also, and rightly, impose standardized testing by grade level across the board. If public money is distilled down to more schools, those schools must prove to state government that students are ready to advance to the next grade level. Parents might also need to provide proof of proficiency and attendance, especially if they home school children.

Another concern is preference-based admissions in public schools; this is already business practice in the private and parochial schools. While in theory there would be public school options, public school systems are likely to discriminate in favor of their residents. Out-of-towners would receive consideration if there is still room, but taxpayers are likely to be extremely concerned about assuming the costs of educating children who live someplace else. There are other municipal services that support the public schools such as police, fire, water and sewer; so in effect, one town will be subsidizing the costs of students from other towns. Is it possible that public schools might charge a premium to non-residents?

On the other hand, there are superintendents who might become public entrepreneurs who will find out-of-towners to be their economic salvation. They can do identify the educational specialties underserved by neighboring municipalities and target students accordingly.

Public schools are also regulated by health and safety standards, including building codes. I don't believe true-choice advocates mean for private, parochial and home schools to become similarly regulated. The same would be true for teaching practices; they would want government out of the classroom. But there will always be extremes: schools based on controversial political or religious philosophies or corporal punishment being two examples from the past. I don't know how these issues would be resolved in a true-choice environment.

Advocates of true choice have usually been considered conservatives, because true choice offers a market-based alternative to the traditional public school bureaucracy. However, in the 1960's there were liberal activists who felt the same way; they developed their own alternative educational options as a challenge to authority. That's one reason communes started; they were living and learning communities.

There would be plenty of challenges to making a true-choice concept succeed. I'd be curious to see if parents, educators and politicians of all persuasions could actually make it work.

Contact Stuart Nachbar at Educated Quest, a blog on education politics, policy and technology or read about his first book, The Sex Ed Chronicle, a novel on education and politics in 1980 New Jersey, at Sex Ed Chronicles.

Other Article Sites

findabook.com  moneycd.info  a-mortgage.info   about-lemon-laws.info  aboutstudentloans.info
all-about-publishing.info  auctions-articles.info  bestcollege-university.com  bestispconnection.com
biblefolder.com  blogger-website.com  books-used.info  brokers-guide.info  buywindows.info  cable-dsl.info
career-miner.com  carpel-tunnel.info  cashinaflash.info  cashloanreviews.info  casinobell.com  chat-house.info
clearmycredit.info  collegeloantips.info  crones.info  depression-articles.info   dirnic.net  dishguides.info
divers-below.com  expodog.info   financewizz.com  fire-insurance.info  getgood.info  handleit.net   it-idea.info
health-supplies.info  hosting-right.com  insidealert.com  insurance-facts.info  jobs-employment.info
justgood.info  lookgold.net   lowcost-travel.info  money-source.info  myhostzone.info  numisblog.com
peoplesearchfinder.info  pr-articles.info  realeas.com   refinancing-guides.info  spyware-remove.info
telelot.info  the-law.info   toppaid.info  travel-deals.info  travelcorrect.com  wedding-guide-site.com
your-blog.info  your-credit.info

Dr. Raphael Longobardi, of the University Orthopaedic Center in Hackensack, NJ Cautions Parents, Coaches & Athletes on Youth Baseball and Softball
Youth baseball and softball season is in full swing, and so are injuries. Dr. Longobardi advises that coaches, parents & athletes educate themselves about potential injuries. An excellent resource available from the American Orthopaedic Society of Sports Medicine.

TeamFanShop to Power Official Online Store for Louisiana State University
Store marks the fifth Division I School to select TeamFanShop in five months.

Sports-O-Zone Inks Deal with Riddell Partners to Fight MRSA Outbreaks in Professional, College, and High School Sports
Indiana based Sports O Zone, a manufacturer of sanitizing and deodorizing equipment has partnered with sports equipment manufacturer and distributor Riddell to fight MRSA and bacterial infection outbreaks in Professional, College and High School Sports.

The Four Types Of Federal Student Loan Consolidation
If you are an American student or one studying in an American school, then you are eligible for federal student loan consolidation from the U.S government.

Salvadore F. Farina, CLU®, CLF®, ChFC®, Named President of The American College Alumni Association
Salvatore F. Farina, CLU®, CLF®, ChFC®, MSM , Managing Partner for New York Life's Long Island General Office has been named the President of The American College Alumni Association. Farina will be responsible for advising the Association on growth initiatives, developing alumni accomplishment recognition, and increasing educational opportunities for association members via the web. Leading the association into its growth phase, he will also preside over annual alumni board meetings in Chicago in 2008, and in New York in 2009.

Existing Conditions Survey at Drew University, Madison, New Jersey, Campus
V.E.C.S. Group LLC. Retained by Design Ideas Group

Youintern.com Partners with Arnold Worldwide to Offer Advertising Internship Interviews for College Students
YouIntern.com, the web's only community of marketing and advertising internship reviews written by students, is excited to announce a partnership with Arnold Worldwide to give college students -- experienced interns -- an exclusive interview at one of Boston's most awarded advertising agencies.

Online Education - A University on Your Desktop
Online education is spreading across the globe like a wildfire fueled by textbooks and periodic tables. Millions who previously thought that a college degree was firmly out of their reach have discovered that all it takes to attend college in today's world are the combination of a few free hours each day and access to the Internet.

University of Calgary Students Sell Cutco Cutlery, Raise Money for Children's Wish Foundation
For the third straight year, students at the University of Calgary's Haskayne School of Business have teamed with Cutco Cutlery and Vector Marketing to raise funds for the Children's Wish Foundation of Canada.

University Lab Technologies Files Patent for Zenstral PMS
University Lab Technologies announced today the filing with the United States patent office for Zenstral PMS, a product for the treatment of Premenstrual Syndrome (PMS).

Top 10 All-Time Greatest Moments of 'The Phat 5' of College Basketball Kentucky, N. Carolina, UCLA, Kansas and Duke at 500
Kentucky vs. N. Carolina the Top 2 "Phat 5" programs of All-Time will square off in historical match-up Saturday on CBS. Texas Western vs. Kentucky and Kentucky vs. Duke head the All-Time list.

Reliv Foundation Builds Feeding Center And School For Impoverished Children In The Philippines
The Reliv Kalogris Foundation today announced the completion of a feeding center and a school for impoverished children in Cavite City, Philippines.

Tips For Gluten Free School Days
Sending a child with Celiac?s disease or gluten sensitivity off to school can be a really daunting prospect for any parent Up until then you have been able to keep a close eye on their diet, and you know exactly what passes their lips

Jim Rygiel, Effects Director for the Lord of the Rings Trilogy and Three Time Academy Award Winner Gives Lecture at the Academy of Art University Scho
On Thursday October 26, 2006, Academy of Art University students packed the Morgan Auditorium to experience first hand the making of the Lord of the Rings. Jim Rygiel, Effects Director for all three Lord of the Rings films, gave a riveting lecture for all Academy of Art University animation students.